
|
SPONSOR: |
Rep.
Gilligan & Rep. Plant & Sen. DeLuca |
|
Reps. Barbieri, Bennett,
Brady, Carson, Jaques, J. Johnson, Q. Johnson, Keeley, Kowalko, Longhurst, M.
Marshall, Mitchell, Mulrooney, Oberle, Schooley, Schwartzkopf, Viola, D.E.
Williams, D.P. Williams; Sens. Blevins, Marshall,
McBride |
|
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES 145th GENERAL ASSEMBLY |
|
HOUSE SUBSTITUTE NO. 1 FOR HOUSE BILL NO. 230 |
|
AN ACT TO AMEND TITLE 19 OF THE |
Section 1. Amend Title 19 of the Delaware Code to create
a new Chapter 35, to read as follows:
“Chapter 35. Workplace Fraud Act.
§ 3501. Definitions.
(a) As used in this chapter:
(1) ‘Construction services’ includes,
without limitation, all building or work on buildings, structures, and
improvements of all types such as bridges, dams, plants, highways, parkways,
streets, tunnels, sewers, mains, power lines, pumping stations, heaving
generators, railways, airports, terminals, docks, piers, wharves, buoys,
jetties, breakwaters, levees, canals, dredging, shoring, rehabilitation and
reactivation of plants, scaffolding, drilling, blasting, excavating, clearing
and landscaping.
(2) ‘Debarment’ means that no public construction
contract in this State shall be bid on, awarded to or received by any employer
or any person, firm, partnership or corporation in which such employer has an
interest who, within 2 years after entry of a judgment pursuant to this
chapter, is adjudicated in violation of this chapter in a subsequent
proceeding, until 3 years have elapsed from the date of the subsequent penalty
judgment.
(3) ‘Department’ shall have the meaning set forth
in § 101(a)(2) of this Title.
(4) ‘Employee’ means any person or entity
directly hired by, or directly permitted to work by an employer in the State of
(5) ‘Employer’ means any individual, partnership,
association, joint stock company, trust, corporation, the administrator or
executor of the estate of a deceased individual or the receiver, trustee or
successor of any of the same employing any person excepting those provided for
in subsection (b) of this section. This chapter does not apply to employees of
the
(6) ‘Exempt Person’ means any individual who:
(A) Performs services in a personal
capacity and who employs no individuals other than a spouse, child, or
immediate family member of the individual;
(B) Performs services free from direction
and control over the means and manner of providing the services, subject only
to the right of the person or entity for whom services are provided to specify
the desired result;
(C) Furnishes the tools and equipment
necessary to provide the services; and
(D) Operates a business that is considered
inseparable from the individual for purposes of taxes, profits, and
liabilities, in which the individual:
(i) Owns all of the assets and profits
of the business; and
(ii) Has sole, unlimited, personal
liability for all of the debts and liabilities of the business; or
alternatively, if the business is organized as a single-person corporate
entity, to which sole, unlimited personal liability does not apply, the
individual must be the sole member of said single-person corporate entity; and
(iii) For which the individual does not pay
taxes for the business separately but reports business income on the
individual’s personal income tax return; and
(E) Exercises complete control over the management and
operations of the business; or
(F)
In the alternative, ‘Exempt
Person’ means an individual who:
(i) Performs the work free from the employer’s control and
direction over the performance of the employee’s services; and
(ii) Is customarily engaged in an independently established
trade, occupation, profession or business; and
(iii)
Performs work which is outside of
the usual course of business of the employer for whom the work is performed.
(7) ‘Independent Contractor’ means an individual
who:
(i) Performs
the work free from the employer’s control and direction over the performance of
the employee’s services; and
(ii) Is customarily engaged in an independently established
trade, occupation, profession or business; and
(iii)
Performs work which is outside of
the usual course of business of the employer for whom the work is performed.
(8) ‘Knowingly’ means having actual
knowledge of, or acting with deliberate ignorance, or reckless disregard for
the prohibition involved.
(9) ‘Public Body’ means:
(A) The State;
(B) A unit of State government or an
instrumentality of the State; or
(C) Any political subdivision, agency, person or
entity that is a party to a contract for which the State appropriated any part
of the funds to be used for payment.
(10) ‘Secretary’ or ‘Secretary of Labor’ shall
have the meaning set forth in § 101(a)(5) of this Title.
(11) ‘Stop Work Order’ means written notice from
the Secretary to an employer to cease or hold work until the employer is given
notice by the Secretary to resume work.
(12) ‘Violate’ or ‘Attempts to Violate’ includes,
but is not limited to, any intent to evade, misrepresent or willfully
non-disclose.
(b) For the purposes of this chapter the officers of a
corporation and any agents having the management thereof who knowingly permit
the corporation to violate this chapter shall be deemed to be the employers of
the employees of the corporation.
§ 3502. Application.
This Act applies only to the construction services industry.
§ 3503. Acts Prohibited.
(a) An employer shall not improperly classify an individual
who performs work for remuneration provided by an employer as an independent
contractor.
(b) An employer has improperly classified an individual when
an employer-employee relationship exists, as determined in paragraph (c) of
this Section, but the employer has not classified the individual as an
employee.
(c) An employer-employee relationship shall be presumed to
exist when work is performed by an individual for remuneration paid by an
employer, unless to the satisfaction of the Department the employer
demonstrates that the individual is an Exempt Person.
(d) A
person shall not knowingly incorporate or form, or assist in the incorporation
or formation of, a corporation, partnership, limited liability corporation, or
other entity, or pay or collect a fee for use of a foreign or domestic corporation,
partnership, limited liability corporation, or other entity for the purpose of
facilitating, or evading detection of, a violation of this Section.
(e) A person shall not knowingly conspire with, aid and abet,
assist, advise, or facilitate an employer with the intent of violating the
provisions of this Act.
(f) The Department shall adopt regulations to further explain
and provide specific examples of subsections (c), (d), and (e) of this Section.
§ 3504. Duties of the Department.
(a) The Department shall administer and enforce this
chapter.
(b) The Department shall investigate, as necessary, to
determine compliance with this Act.
(c) As part of the Department's investigation, the Department
is permitted to:
(1) Enter and inspect the premises or place of
business, employment, or work site, and upon demand examine and copy, wholly or
partly, any or all books, registers, payrolls, and other records, including
those required to be made, kept and preserved under this chapter or any
regulation published thereunder;
(2) Question an employer, employee, or other
person in the premises, place of business or employment, or work site;
(3) Require
from any employer full and correct statements in writing, including sworn
statements, upon forms prescribed or approved by the Department, with respect
to the payment of wages, hours, names, addresses, and such other information
pertaining to remuneration pertaining to employees, or require from any
employer complete and accurate copies of written notices pertaining to
independent contractors, which are maintained by the employer pursuant to § 3511(c)
of this Act;
(4) Investigate such facts, conditions, or
matters as the Department may deem necessary or appropriate to determine
whether a provision of this Act or any regulation published thereunder has been
or is being violated; and
(5)
Administer oaths and examine witnesses under oath, issue subpoenas, compel the
attendance of witnesses and the production of papers, books, accounts, records,
payrolls, documents and testimony, and to take depositions and affidavits in
any proceeding before it, and, in case of failure of any person or entity to
comply with any subpoena lawfully issued, or on the refusal of any witness to
testify to any matter regarding which the witness may be lawfully interrogated,
the Superior Court, on application by the Department, shall compel obedience as
in the case of disobedience of the requirements of a subpoena issued from such
Court or a refusal to testify therein.
(d) Following an investigation in which the Department makes
an initial determination that an employer has violated one or more of the
provisions of this Chapter or any regulation published hereunder, the
Department shall notify an employer of such initial determination and shall
provide the employer with an opportunity to appeal the Department’s
determination in accordance with the Administrative Procedures Act. Following notification of the employer and
the opportunity for an administrative appeal of the Department’s initial determination,
the Department may institute actions in the Superior Court for penalties for
any violation of this chapter or any regulation published hereunder.
(e) Nothing contained in this Act shall be deemed a
limitation on any power or authority of the Department under any law of this
State which may be otherwise applicable to the Department’s ability to
administer or enforce the provisions of this Act.
§3505. Penalties.
(a) Any employer who violates or fails to comply with § 3503
of this Act or any regulation published thereunder shall be deemed in violation
of § 3503, and shall be subject to a civil penalty of not less than $1,000, and
not more than $5,000, for each such violation.
Each employee who is not properly classified in violation of § 3503
shall be considered a separate violation for purposes of this Section.
(b) An employer that fails to produce to the Department the
books and records requested pursuant to § 3504(c) of this Act within 30 days of
the employer’s receipt of a written request sent to the employer via federal
express or certified mail from the Department, in the course of an
investigation to determine whether the employer is in compliance with the
provisions of this Chapter, may be subject to a stop-work order, and may be subject
to an administrative penalty, not to exceed $500 per day, for each day that the
requested records are not produced after the date on which the employer
receives the written request from the Department.
(c) An employer who discharges or in any manner discriminates
against a person because that person has made a complaint or has given
information to the Department pursuant to the provisions of this Act, or
because the person has caused to be instituted or is about to cause to be
instituted any proceedings under this Act, or has testified or is about to
testify in any such proceedings, shall be subject to a civil penalty of not
less than $5,000, and not more than $10,000, for each such violation.
(d) A person who knowingly incorporates or forms, or assists in
the incorporation or formation of, a corporation, partnership, limited
liability corporation, or other entity, or pay or collect a fee for use of a
foreign or domestic corporation, partnership, limited liability corporation, or
other entity for the purpose of facilitating, or evading detection of, a
violation of this Chapter, shall be subject to a civil penalty not to exceed
$20,000.
(e) A person who knowingly conspires with, aids and abets,
assists, advises, or facilitates an employer with the intent of violating this
Chapter shall be subject to a civil penalty not to exceed $20,000.
(f) Notwithstanding
subsections (a) through (e) of this Section, an employer may be subject to a
stop-work order, and may be ordered to make restitution, pay any interest due
and otherwise comply with all applicable laws and regulations by multiple final
determinations of the Department or orders of a courts, including but not
limited to, the Division of Unemployment Insurance, the Department of
Insurance, the Office of Workers’ Compensation, the Division of Revenue, the
Office of the Attorney General, or any other agency, department or division of
the state.
(g) Notwithstanding subsections (a) through (e)
of this Section, an employer found by any court or the Department to be in
violation of this chapter shall be required, within 30 days of the final order:
(1) To pay restitution to or on behalf of any
individual not properly classified; and
(2) To otherwise come into compliance with all
applicable labor laws, including those related to income tax withholding,
unemployment insurance, wage laws, and workers’ compensation.
(h) Notwithstanding subsections (a) through (e) of
this Section, an employer who has been found by a final order of a court or the
Department to have violated this Chapter twice in a two year period:
(1) Shall be assessed an administrative
penalty of $20,000 for each employee that was not properly classified, and may
be debarred for five (5) years; and
(2) Notwithstanding paragraph (1) of this
subsection, an employer that is fined or debarred in accordance with this
Section may be ordered to make restitution, pay any interest due, and otherwise
comply with all applicable laws and regulations by orders of a court and all
relevant departments, agencies and divisions, including the Division of
Unemployment Insurance, the Department of Insurance, the Office of Workers’
Compensation, the Division of Revenue, and the Office of the Attorney General.
(i) Any penalty issued under this Section against
an employer shall be in effect against any successor corporation or business
entity that:
(1) Has one or more of the same
principals or officers as the employer against whom the penalty was assessed;
and
(2) Is engaged in the same or equivalent
trade or activity.
§ 3506. Provisions of law may not be waived by
agreement.
Except as provided in this
chapter, no provision of this chapter may in any way be contravened or set
aside by private agreement.
§ 3507. Department Collaboration With Other State
Agencies.
As authorized by State and
federal law, divisions within the Department, the Division of Unemployment
Insurance, the Office of Workers’ Compensation, the Department of Insurance,
the Office of the Attorney General, the Division of Revenue and other departments,
agencies, or divisions of the state shall cooperate and share information
concerning any suspected failure to properly classify an individual as an
employee.
§ 3508. Cause of Action by
Employees or Other Individuals for Violations of Certain Provisions of this Act
(a) An employee or other individual who alleges a violation of
§ 3503 or § 3509 of this Act must first notify the Department in writing and
request an investigation by the Department, pursuant to § 3504 or § 3509(b)(2),
as applicable, of the alleged violation.
If the Department fails to investigate or fails to commence an action in
the Superior Court pursuant to § 3504(d) or § 3509(b)(2) ,within ninety days of
receipt of written notice of an alleged violation of § 3503 or § 3509, the
person alleging a violation of said section may bring a civil action for
appropriate declaratory relief, or actual damages, or both. A civil action pursuant to this Section must
be brought within 3 years after the occurrence of the alleged violation of the
applicable provision(s) of this Act.
(b) An action commenced pursuant to subsection (a) of this
section may be brought in the Superior Court in the county where the alleged
violation occurred, the county where the complainant resides, or the county
where the employer against whom the civil complaint is filed resides or where
the employer’s principal place of business is located.
(c) As used in subsection (a) of this section, ‘damages’ means
treble damages for lost wages or benefits caused by each violation of this
chapter. ‘Damages’ also includes the
payment of back wages, fringe benefits, seniority rights, actual damages,
litigation costs and attorney(s) fees, or any combination of these remedies.
§ 3509. Retaliation Prohibited.
(a) An employer may not discriminate in any manner or take
adverse action against any person because the person:
(1) Files a complaint with the employer
or the Department alleging that the employer violated any provision of this Act
or any regulation adopted under this Act;
(2) Brings an action under this Act or a
proceeding involving a violation of this Act;
(3) Testifies in an action authorized
under this chapter or a proceeding involving a violation of the provisions of
this Act or any regulation adopted by this chapter; or
(4) Assists in an investigation by
providing information to a litigant in a civil action, the Department or
another State agency in proceedings as provided by this Act.
(b) A person who believes that an employer has discriminated
in any manner or taken adverse action against the person in violation of
subsection (a) of this Section:
(1) May submit to the Department a
written verified complaint that alleges the discrimination and that includes
the signature of the complainant; and
(2) Upon receipt of a complaint pursuant to this
Section, the Department will determine if an investigation is warranted.
§ 3510. Provisions Relating to Contracts with Public
Bodies.
(a) Where, after investigation, the Department determines that
an employer engaged in work on a public works project is in violation of this
chapter or regulations adopted pursuant to this chapter, the Department shall
promptly notify the public body.
(b) The public body shall:
(1) On notification of the violation
pursuant to paragraph A of this section, withhold from payment due the employer
an amount that is sufficient to:
(A) Pay restitution to each employee for
the full amount of wages due; and
(B) Pay any benefits, taxes, or other
contributions that are required by law to be paid on behalf of the employee.
(2) Release:
(A) On issuance of a final order of a
court or the Department, the full amount of the withheld funds; and
(B) On an adverse final order of a court
or the Department, the balance of the withheld funds after all obligations is
satisfied pursuant to paragraph (1) of this Section.
(c) Subject to the process set forth in this Section:
(1) An
employer found to be in violation of this Chapter more than twice in a two year
period may be subject to debarment.
(2) The Department shall file with the
Office of Management and Budget, the Division of Revenue, the Division of
Unemployment Insurance, the Department of Insurance, the Office of Workers’
Compensation, and the Office of the Attorney General, a list of employers who
are subject to debarment.
A
debarment under this Section shall be in effect against any successor
corporation or business entity that:
(A) Has one or more of the same principals
or officers as the employer against whom the debarment was imposed; and
(B) Is engaged in the same or equivalent
trade or activity.
§ 3511. Employer Record
Keeping Requirements.
(a) An employer shall keep, for at least three (3) years, in
or about its place of business, records of the employer containing the
following information:
(1) The name, address, occupation, and
classification of each employee or independent contractor;
(2) The rate of pay of each employee or
method of payment for the independent contractor;
(3) The amount that is paid each pay
period to each employee;
(4) The hours that each employee works
each day and each work week;
(5) For all individuals who are not
classified as employees, evidence including the written notice required by
subsection(c) of this Section and any other evidence in the employer’s
possession which the employer believes is relevant to determine whether each
individual is an Exempt Person, an independent contractor or an employee; and
(b) An
employer shall provide each individual classified as an independent contractor
or Exempt Person with written notice of such classification at the time the
individual is hired.
(c) The written notice shall:
(1) Include an explanation of the
implications of the individual’s classification as an independent contractor or
Exempt Person rather than as an employee;
(2) Include contact information for the
Department;
(3) Be provided in English and Spanish;
and
(4) Be signed by both the employer and
the independent contractor or by the employer and the Exempt Person, as the
case may be.
(d) Failure to comply with the written notice requirement in
subsection (c) of this Section shall be evidence of a knowing violation by the
employer of § 3503 of this Act. The
employer shall be liable for an administrative penalty of $500.00 for each
individual that the employer failed to notify.
(e) An employer who complies with the written notice
requirement in subsection (c) of this Section shall be presumed to have acted
in good faith in determining whether to classify an individual as an employee,
an independent contractor or an Exempt Person pursuant to § 3503 of this Act.
(f) The Department shall adopt regulations establishing
specific requirements for the content and form of the notice within one year of
the effective date of this Act, and, notwithstanding the provisions of subsection
(b) of this Section, the adoption of such regulations shall be a prerequisite
to an employer’s obligation to furnish the notice.
§ 3512. Regulations.
The Department shall have the power to make
and revise or rescind such regulations as it may deem necessary or appropriate
to administer or enforce the provisions of this Act and any such regulations
shall, except as may be otherwise provided by the Department, take effect upon
publication.
§ 3513.
Distribution of Proceeds from Civil Penalties Obtained Pursuant to this
Chapter
(a) All civil penalties and other revenue collected pursuant
to this Act shall be paid to the General Fund of the State of
§ 3514. Short title.
This chapter shall be known as the
‘Workplace Fraud Act.’”
Section 2. This
Act shall take effect ninety days after its enactment into law.
SYNOPSIS
|
This
Act applies to the construction services industry and provides for
administrative remedies and civil penalties against an employer who knowingly
misclassifies an employee as an independent contractor when an
employer-employee relationship exists according to the criteria set forth in
Section 3501. State and federal
government agencies, sole proprietors and single-member corporate or business
entities are exempt from the requirements of this Act. Section
3503 sets forth the acts prohibited. Specifically, it prohibits an employer
from knowingly misclassifying an employee as an independent contractor unless
the employee or individual is exempt from the Act. Similarly, it prohibits an
employer or person from knowingly incorporating or forming a corporation or
other business entity for the purpose of evading the provisions of the
Act. Section
3504 sets forth the duties of the Department of Labor to enforce the Act. The Department is given the authority to
investigate, as necessary, to determine compliance with the Act. Its investigation powers include the
authority to conduct an on-site inspection of an employer’s business records,
to require an employer to provide certain information, and to administer
oaths, issue supoenas and examine witnesses to determine whether a violation
occurred. Section 3504 also permits the Department of Labor to, following
administrative review, institute actions in the Superior Court for penalties
for any violation of the Act. Section
3505 enumerates the applicable penalties for violations of this Act,
including civil penalties for failure to properly classify an employee, and
potential administrative penalties, including fines and a stop-work order,
for an employer who refuses to produce to the Department of labor certain
requested materials within 30 days of the request. An employer who is found by a final order
of a court or the Department to have violated this Chapter twice in a two year
period is subject to an administrative penalty of $20,000 and possible
debarment. Section
3506 prohibits waiver of the provisions of this Act by contract or agreement. Section
3507 authorizes the Department of Labor to collaborate with other State agencies
and share information concerning any potential violations of this Act. Section
3508 allows an employee who alleges a violation of certain provisions of the
Act to, after notifying the employer, file an action in the Superior Court
for declaratory relief or monetary damages. Section
3509 prohibits employers from retaliating against any individual who files a
complaint or provides information to the Department pursuant to this Act. Section
3510 establishes certain procedures that the Department must follow for
notifying a public body after it finds a violation by an employer working on
a public works project. Section
3511 provides that employers must keep certain records of employees and of
independent contractors and must provide specific notice to each person
classified as an independent contractor or exempt person. Section
3512 gives the Department the authority to adopt regulations as necessary to
enforce this Act. Section
3513 provides that all civil penalties and other revenue collected pursuant
to this Act shall be deposited into the General Fund. |