SPONSOR: |
Sen. Peterson & Rep. J. Johnson & Rep. M.
Smith |
|
Sens.
Henry, Townsend; Rep. Potter |
DELAWARE STATE SENATE 148th GENERAL ASSEMBLY |
SENATE SUBSTITUTE NO. 1 FOR SENATE BILL NO. 163 |
AN ACT TO AMEND TITLE 11 OF THE DELAWARE CODE RELATING TO HABITUAL OFFENDERS. |
Section 1. Amend § 4214 of Title 11 of the Delaware Code by making deletions as shown by strike through and insertions as shown by underline as follows:
§ 4214 Habitual criminal; life sentence
(a) Any person who has been 2 times convicted of a Title 11 violent
felony, or attempt to commit such a violent felony, as defined in § 4201(c) of
this title under the laws of this State, and/or any comparable violent felony
as defined by another state, United States or any territory of the United
States, and who shall thereafter be convicted of a subsequent violent felony,
or attempt to commit such a violent felony, as defined in Section 4201(c), or 4
times convicted of any felony under the laws of this State, and/or any other
state, United States or any territory of the United States, is declared to be an habitual criminal and
the court, upon the State’s petition, shall impose the applicable minimum
sentence pursuant to (b), (c) or (d) of this section and may, in its
discretion, impose a sentence of up to life imprisonment, unless the felony
conviction allows and results in the imposition of capital punishment.
(b) Any person who has been 3 times convicted of a felony under the
laws of this State, and/or any other state, United States or any territory of
the United States, and who shall thereafter be convicted of a 4th or
subsequent felony, which is the person’s first Title 11 violent felony, or
attempt to commit such a violent felony, as defined in § 4201(c) of this title,
shall receive a minimum sentence of one-half of the statutory maximum penalty
provided elsewhere in this title, unless the maximum statutory penalty is life
in which case the minimum sentence shall be 30 years, for the 4th or
subsequent felony which forms the basis of the States petition to have the
person declared to be an habitual criminal, up to life imprisonment, unless the
felony conviction allows and results in the imposition of capital
punishment.
(c) Any person who has been 2 times convicted of a felony under the
laws of this State, and/or any other state, United States or any territory of
the United States, and 1 time convicted of a Title 11 violent felony, or
attempt to commit such a violent felony, as defined in § 4201(c) of this title
under the laws of this State, and/or any comparable violent felony as defined
by another state, United States or any territory of the United States, and who
shall thereafter be convicted of a 4th or subsequent violent felony,
or attempt to commit such a violent felony, as defined by § 4201(c) of this
title, shall receive a minimum sentence of the statutory maximum penalty
provided elsewhere in this title for the 4th or subsequent felony
which forms the basis of the State's petition to have the person declared to be
an habitual criminal, up to life imprisonment, unless the felony conviction
allows and results in the imposition of capital punishment.
(d) Any person who has been 2 times convicted of a Title 11 violent
felony, or attempt to commit such a violent felony, as defined in § 4201(c) of
this title under the laws of this State, and/or any comparable violent felony
as defined by another state, United States or any territory of the United
States, and who shall thereafter be convicted of a 3rd or subsequent felony which is a violent
felony, or an attempt to commit such a violent felony, as defined in § 4201(c),
shall receive a minimum sentence of the statutory maximum statutory penalty
provided elsewhere in this title for the 3rd or subsequent violent
felony which forms the basis of the State's petition to have the person
declared to be an habitual criminal, up to life imprisonment, unless the felony
conviction allows and results in the imposition of capital punishment.
(e) Notwithstanding any provision of this title to the contrary, any
sentence imposed pursuant to (b), (c), or (d) of this section shall not be
subject to suspension by the court, and shall be served in its entirety at full
custodial Level V institutional setting without the benefit of probation or
parole, except that any such sentence shall be subject to the provisions of §§
4205(h), 4381 and 4382 of this title.
For purposes of the computation of good time under § 4381 of this title,
a life sentence imposed pursuant only to § 4214 of this title shall equate to a
sentence of 45 years.
(f) Notwithstanding any statute, court
rule or regulation to the contrary, any person sentenced as an habitual
criminal prior to the date of enactment of this section shall be eligible to
petition the Superior Court for sentence modification after the person has
served a sentence of incarceration equal to any applicable mandatory sentence
otherwise required by this section or the statutes describing said offense or
offenses, whichever is greater. Absent
extraordinary circumstances, the petitioner may only file one application for
sentence modification under this section.
A Superior Court Judge upon consideration of a petition filed pursuant
to this subsection may modify, reduce or suspend such petitioner’s sentence,
excepting any minimum or mandatory sentence required by this section or the
statutes describing said offense or offenses.
If a Superior Court judge modifies such petitioner’s sentence, the judge
may impose a suspended sentence that includes a probationary term. Nothing in this section, however, shall
require the Court to grant such a petitioner a sentence modification pursuant
to this section. For the purposes of
this subsection, the “applicable mandatory sentence” shall be calculated by
reference to the penalties prescribed for the relevant offense or offenses by
this Code as of the date of enactment of this section, unless said offense has
been repealed, in which case the penalties prescribed by this Code at the time
of the Act repealing said offense shall be controlling. The Superior Court shall establish rules to
implement this subsection which are consistent with the statute, and those
rules shall also provide that all petitions filed pursuant to this subsection
where the felony establishing an inmate as a habitual offender was a Title 16
offense are heard first, followed by all petitions filed pursuant to this
subsection where the felony establishing an inmate as a habitual offender was a
crime against property, followed by all other petitions. The rules shall also provide for an initial
review, including review of a formal response by the Department of Justice
after consulting with the victim(s), of sentence modification petitions
involving crimes against persons or property, for the purpose of ensuring that
victims are not inconvenienced by petitions that should be denied based upon
the documents submitted; in cases not denied in this manner, all victims shall
be given an opportunity to be heard. The
Superior Court’s review of any petitions filed pursuant to this paragraph shall
include a review of the applicant’s prior criminal history, including arrests
and convictions, a review of the applicant’s conduct while incarcerated, and
available evidence as to the likelihood that the applicant will reoffend if
released. In all cases where sentence
modifications are granted, modified sentences should provide for step-down
provisions to ensure successful reintegration of persons into the community. By
January 1, 2017, the Department of Correction shall notify any criminal
defendant whose Level V sentence was imposed under a statutory sentencing
regimen which was subsequently changed in a manner that reduced the sentence
applicable to the defendant’s convictions. The Department of Correction shall similarly
notify the attorney of record, and if the attorney of record is unavailable to
receive notice, the Office of Defense Services.
(a) Any
person who has been 3 times convicted of a felony, other than those which are
specifically mentioned in subsection (b) of this section, under the laws of
this State, and/or any other state, United States or any territory of the
United States, and who shall thereafter be convicted of a subsequent felony of
this State is declared to be an habitual criminal, and the court in which such
fourth or subsequent conviction is had, in imposing sentence, may in its
discretion, impose a sentence of up to life imprisonment upon the person so
convicted. Notwithstanding any provision of this title to the contrary, any
person sentenced pursuant to this subsection shall receive a minimum sentence
which shall not be less than the statutory maximum penalty provided elsewhere
in this title for the fourth or subsequent felony which forms the basis of the
State's petition to have the person declared to be an habitual criminal except
that this minimum provision shall apply only when the fourth or subsequent
felony is a Title 11 violent felony, as defined in § 4201(c) of this title.
Notwithstanding any provision of this title to the contrary, any sentence of
life imprisonment imposed pursuant to this subsection shall not be subject to
suspension by the court, and shall be served in its entirety at a full
custodial Level V institutional setting without the benefit of probation,
parole, earned good time or any other reduction. Notwithstanding any provision
of this title to the contrary, any sentence of less than life imprisonment imposed
pursuant to this subsection shall not be subject to suspension by the court,
and shall be served in its entirety at a full custodial Level V institutional
setting without the benefit of probation or parole, except that any such
sentence shall be subject to the provisions of §§ 4205(h), 4217, 4381 and 4382
of this title.
(b) Any person who has been 2 times
convicted of a felony or an attempt to commit a felony hereinafter specifically
named, under the laws of this State, and/or any other state, United States or
any territory of the United States, and who shall thereafter be convicted of a
subsequent felony hereinafter specifically named, or an attempt to commit such
specific felony, is declared to be an habitual criminal, and the court in which
such third or subsequent conviction is had, in imposing sentence, shall impose
a life sentence upon the person so convicted unless the subsequent felony
conviction requires or allows and results in the imposition of capital
punishment. Such sentence shall not be subject to the probation or parole
provisions of Chapter 43 of this title.
Such felonies shall be:
Section Crime
803 Arson
in the first degree
826 Burglary
in the first degree
825 Burglary
in the second degree
826A
Home Invasion
636 Murder
in the first degree
635 Murder
in the second degree
632 Manslaughter
783 Kidnapping
in the second degree
783A
Kidnapping in the first degree
606 Abuse
of a pregnant female in the first degree
613 Assault
in the first degree
[Former] 615
Assault by abuse
Former 763 Rape
in the second degree
Former 764 Rape
in the first degree
Former 766 Sodomy
in the first degree
832
Robbery in the first degree
836
Carjacking in the first degree
Former 771
Unlawful sexual penetration in the second degree
Former 772 Unlawful sexual penetration in the first
degree
Former 773 Sexual intercourse in the third degree
Former 774 Unlawful sexual intercourse in the second
degree
Former 775 Unlawful sexual intercourse in the first
degree
771 Rape in the third degree
772 Rape in the second degree
773 Rape in the first degree
778(1), (2) or (3) Sexual
Abuse of a Child by a Person
in
a Position of Trust, Authority or
Supervision in the First Degree
1447A Possession of a firearm during the commission
of a felony
Title 16, Section Crime
Former 4751
Manufacture, delivery or possession with intent to manufacture or
deliver a narcotic drug
Former 4752
Manufacture, delivery or possession
with intent to manufacture or deliver
nonnarcotic, controlled substance
Former 4752A
Unlawful delivery or attempt to deliver
noncontrolled substance
Former 4753A
Trafficking in marijuana, cocaine,
illegal drugs or methamphetamine.
4752
Drug dealing—aggravated possession; class B felony
4753
Drug dealing—aggravated possession; class C felony
4754
Drug dealing—aggravated possession; class D felony
4755
Aggravated possession; class E felony
Notwithstanding any provision of this
title to the contrary, any sentence imposed pursuant to this subsection shall
not be subject to suspension by the court, and shall be served in its entirety
at a full custodial Level V institutional setting without benefit of probation,
parole, earned good time or any other reduction.
(c) Any person who has been
convicted for an offense which occurred within this State prior to July 1,
1973, of any of the hereinafter enumerated crimes shall be considered as having
been convicted previously of the crimes specified in subsection (b) of this
section for purposes of the operation of this section and § 4215 of this title.
Any person convicted under the laws of another state, the United States or any
territory of the United States of any felony the same as or equivalent to any
of the above or hereinafter named felonies is an habitual offender for the
purposes of this section and § 4215 of this title.
Such felonies include:
Arson in the first degree,
Burglary in the first degree,
Burglary in the second degree,
Murder in the first degree,
Murder in the second degree,
Manslaughter except involuntary,
Manslaughter by motor vehicle,
Assault with intent to murder,
Poisoning with intent to murder,
Kidnapping,
Abducting child under 12 years,
Kidnapping child under 15 years,
Maiming by lying in wait,
Maiming without lying in wait,
Rape,
Assault with intent to commit rape,
Robbery,
Assault with intent to commit robbery.
(d) A conviction of rape or
kidnapping under either § 763 or § 783 of this title, as the same existed and
were defined prior to the amendment of this section, shall be considered a
prior conviction for the purpose of the effectiveness and applicability of this
subsection, this section and § 4215 of this title.
SYNOPSIS
This Act makes changes to the existing habitual criminal statute by focusing penalties on Title 11 felonies, eliminating a mandatory minimum sentence of life imprisonment, and providing a mechanism for those convicted under existing law to petition the court for a sentence modification. This Act provides for enhanced penalties for habitual criminals convicted of multiple felonies and distinguishes between Title 11 violent felonies and all other Title 11 felonies. Under this Act, a person is declared a habitual criminal upon conviction of a third Title 11 violent felony or a fourth Title 11 felony of any kind. If a person is convicted of a Title 11 felony that is designated as a violent felony, and has prior convictions of three felonies of any kind, the person will receive a minimum mandatory sentence equal to one half the statutory maximum penalty allowed for the final conviction. If however, one of the three prior felonies is a Title 11 felony that is designated as a violent felony, the person will receive a minimum mandatory sentence equal to the statutory maximum penalty allowed for the final conviction If a person is convicted of a third Title 11 felony that is designated as a violent felony, the person will receive a minimum mandatory sentence equal to the statutory maximum penalty allowed for the final conviction There is no provision requiring a mandatory life sentence, though the judge has discretion to impose a life sentence for any person declared a habitual criminal. This Act further provides an opportunity for those who were convicted under the existing law to apply for a sentence modification once the person has served any applicable minimum mandatory sentence. Such applications for sentence modifications will be subject to court rules promulgated by the Superior Court in accordance with the requirements of the statute. |
Author: Senator Peterson